April 18, 2014: Should You Take Comments on Your Blog?A reader recently e-mailed us asking why we don’t take comments on the Didit Marketing Blog. It’s a fair question — after all, comments — at least in theory — can lead to greater engagement, longer time spent on site, and perhaps a greater chance that a reader will subscribe or take other positive action.

Sometimes it’s good to maintain an “I/Thou” distance from your audience (just ask The New Yorker Magazine, which doesn’t host comments). It’s neither wise nor necessary to make every one of your online statements an invitation to a debate.
From a webmaster’s perspective, however, hosting comments on a blog can provide major headaches, among them:

  • Even if your blog content is stunning (or as Rand Fishkin terms it, “runaway amazing,” ), there’s nothing sadder than a great article sitting on a site with zero comments. Even sites with major traffic suffer from this problem. An article lacking comments  shouldn’t make your site look boring, but it does.
  • Comments attract spam, quick hit replies that add nothing to the conversation, irrelevant links from “bad neighborhoods,” and other low-level content. Do you really want this kind of graffiti on your editorial wall?
  • You’re going to have to task somebody with managing comments. You’re also going to have to come up with a policy governing how you will respond. Do you really have the bandwidth for all of this editorial grunt work?
  • Comments provide — in certain circumstances — a way for hackers to hijack your web property.
  • Comments aren’t a “business-friendly” communications channel.  If someone really wants to communicate with you for a business reason, move the conversation to e-mail – it’s a lot more professional.
  • Sometimes it’s good to maintain an “I/Thou” distance from your audience (just ask The New Yorker Magazine, which doesn’t host comments). It’s neither wise nor necessary to make every one of your online statements an invitation to a debate.

On the other hand, social networks are terrific places to host comments — they were built for this purpose, after all.  Comment plug-ins and/or widgets are available from the big social networks, including Facebook and Google Plus.  Short-form micro-blogging platforms such as Twitter are great places to move links to your articles into other peoples’ networks.

Keep the chatting — and any spam or sniping — on these networks, and save your blog for what it does best: showcasing your thought leadership.

Didit Editorial
The owner of this website has made a committment to accessibility and inclusion, please report any problems that you encounter using the contact form on this website. This site uses the WP ADA Compliance Check plugin to enhance accessibility.